Categories
Movies and TV Reviews

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

So, Square Enix liked the first season of Fullmetal Alchemist so much that they gave the go-ahead for another round, called Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. I’ve watched the first three episodes, and figure that’s enough to give a bit of comment.

First of all, rather than follow on from the end of the original series (or the subsequent movie), the team has decided to start again. The first episode is set after Edward becoming a State Alchemist, but before they go to Lior (where the church of Leto is). The second is a flashback to the Elrics’ youth, attempt to resurrect their mother, and Edward’s State Alchemy Exam. The third is a rehash of the original Lior incident.

It’s readily apparent that instead of being suppemental to the original FMA, Brotherhood is a complete reset. Familiar incidents are given new, and sometimes contradictory details. There’s some implications (like Lust’s reference to the homunculi’s Father) that this is going to follow the manga much more closely.

I’ve got my reservations about how this will turn out, as the manga is a long story arc, and while the original anime series was different, it was entirely self-contained and strongly plotted. There are already intimations that Brotherhood may not be anywhere near as focused.

Categories
Movies and TV

Wither Smallville?

With the completion of BSG, I’ve found it hard to find something to write about. I’ve been following Smallville for years, but the quality of the writing is so all over the shop that I’m just not as invested as I used to be.

Maybe it’s the shift of focus to Metropolis (though that was inevitable), but the show feels stagnant. Although we’ve finally ditched Lana (kinda — she’s still alive), the metaplot is slowly circling this inevitable showdown between Doomsday and Clark, but that’s nowhere near as exciting as Oliver forming the Justice League, or Clark taking on General Zod, or even just having Kara around.

I guess that there aren’t enough of the good characters for Clark to play off. Right now it’s lots of Chloe, some Lois, some Tess, and a little Davis. Gone are the days of the whole Kent family, and both the Luthors.

Actually, that’s probably it. Without Lex and Lionel, the show has no real heavyweight manipulators (or actors for that matter), so the plot feels either contrived or simplistic.

Categories
Movies and TV Reviews

BSG: Return of the King

I know I’ve been slack and not kept up with the last stretch of episodes. Of the three between “No Exit” and “Daybreak”, I really liked “Someone to Watch Over Me” and was underwhelmed by “Islanded in the Stream of Stars”. I’ll probably go re-watch the former and hopefully review it, while glossing over the others.

But seeing as it was the finale, I don’t think I can delay writing something about “Daybreak”. Possible spoilers after the jump.

Categories
Movies and TV Reviews

Quo Vadis?

Watchmen is one of those dangerous works in contemporary culture for anybody to touch. It’s a seminal work in the superhero comic genre, which comes with all kinds of nasty fanboy baggage, as well as being highly political. It also presents many challenges for a film maker, even given today’s amazing technology and recent successes with comic book adaptations.

And so it was with a little trepidation (mitigated somewhat by FSR‘s coverage of the whole thing) that I went to see it. I’ve only recently read the original graphic novel myself, but I could already see that the plot was compex and the visuals and narrative subtly nuanced such that there was plenty of room for error.

Overall, I was happy with Zack Snyder’s work. Obviously his previous successes with adapting comics to the big screen have not been flukes. The script kept the essentials of the long and detailed plot together coherently, and captured the essence of the story, and the dialogue was engaging enough (in that stilted comic book way) that I kept my disbelief suspended for the whole movie.

Categories
Movies and TV

Skinjobs in BSG 1980?

Just quickly before I head to bed. Somewhere out in the blogosphere, I stumbled upon this little nugget: BSG 1980 had Cylons that looked like humans!

Furthermore, it sounds like the explanation for such anthropomorphism is brought across from old to new:

Dr. Zee gets a lengthy scene to explain how this came about. His explanation seems a bit long and ponderous until you realize he’s just spent 4 minutes explaining what the new series has taken 4 whole seasons to get around to. Huh.

I might have to watch these episodes. I should have realised that all that nonsense about it all “has happened before and will happened again” was more than just spiritual nonsense from inside the setting. It’s breaking the fourth wall.

Grr.